Soft opt-in vs explicit consent: who an online shop may email
Four people bought the same phone case from your shop last week. Anna ticked "Email me offers" at checkout. Ben didn't, but your checkout also had a "Don't email me offers" box and he left that empty too. Chris bought the case through a marketplace. Dimitra paid at the point of sale (POS) in your physical store and gave her email address for the receipt; nobody mentioned offers.
Next week you send a Black Friday email. Done right, it can go to Anna, and to Ben as long as it's about products like the one he bought. It can't go to Chris or Dimitra.
The difference is the line between explicit consent and the soft opt-in, the exception that lets a shop email its own customers. This guide explains both, what double opt-in adds, which records to keep and how long a soft opt-in lasts. It is general information, not legal advice: these rules are set in national law, so ask a lawyer about your own case.
MailPilot, our email marketing for WooCommerce, keeps a consent record for every customer and checks it before each email; the last section shows how.
Two sets of rules decide who you may email
- The ePrivacy Directive (2002/58/EC, Article 13) decides whether you need consent. Marketing email needs the recipient's prior consent (13(1)), with one exception for your own customers (13(2)): the soft opt-in. Each country has its own version: in Greece, Article 11 of Law 3471/2006; in the UK, regulation 22 of PECR.
- The GDPR (Regulation 2016/679) decides what valid consent is, and gives everyone the right to object to direct marketing at any time.
For a typical shop:
| Who | Marketing email? | On what basis |
|---|---|---|
| Ticked an empty newsletter box, or signed up in a form | Yes | Explicit consent |
| Bought from you online, was offered a clear opt-out and didn't use it | Yes, about your similar products | Soft opt-in |
| Bought from you, then unsubscribed | No | Only a new sign-up brings them back |
| Bought from you through a marketplace | No, unless they sign up with you | — |
| Gave an email at your store's POS for the receipt | Only if staff asked for consent or offered a clear opt-out there and then | Consent or soft opt-in |
Explicit consent: what makes it valid
Consent is one of the GDPR's legal bases (Article 6(1)(a)), defined as a "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication" of a person's wishes, given "by a statement or by a clear affirmative action" (Article 4(11)). For a newsletter:
- Freely given. Buying can't depend on it (Article 7(4)). "By placing your order you agree to receive our emails" is not consent.
- Specific and informed. Say who will email them and about what: "Email me offers and new products from Example Shop."
- Unambiguous. The person acts: ticks an empty box, or types an address into a sign-up form. "Silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity" don't count (Recital 32).
- Separate from your other terms (Article 7(2)), and as easy to withdraw as to give (Article 7(3)).
Then there's proof: the shop "shall be able to demonstrate" that the person consented (Article 7(1)), and the European Data Protection Board says that pointing at a correctly configured website isn't enough (Guidelines 05/2020 on consent, paragraph 108).
The soft opt-in: emailing your own customers
Article 13(2) lets you email a customer without asking first when all of these hold:
- You got the address yourself, from the customer, in a sale. Not from a partner, a marketplace or a list.
- You email about your own similar products or services. The UK regulator's test is what the customer would reasonably expect: a grocery buyer expects grocery emails, not insurance (ICO guidance).
- You offered a clear, free and easy way to refuse when you collected the address. In practice, a box at checkout: "Don't email me offers." An opt-out first offered in the order confirmation is too late, the ICO says.
- Every email repeats the chance to refuse, with an unsubscribe link that works without logging in.
- They haven't refused, at checkout or since.
PECR regulation 22(3) sets the same conditions in the UK. Under the GDPR, the legal basis is usually legitimate interests: the regulation itself says processing for direct marketing "may be regarded as carried out for a legitimate interest" (Recital 47). The soft opt-in never covers other companies' products, or anyone who said no.
Unsubscribes and objections are final
Everyone may object to direct marketing "at any time", and once they do, their data "shall no longer be processed for such purposes" (GDPR Article 21(2) and (3)). You must point the right out explicitly, at the latest in your first message (21(4)), and every marketing email needs a valid address for opting out (ePrivacy Article 13(4)).
Regulators enforce it: Greece's data protection authority fined a mobile operator €60,000 under Article 21(3) for five promotional texts sent after the customer had objected (decision 20/2023).
So a new purchase doesn't undo an unsubscribe. The ICO puts it plainly: after an opt-out, you may market to that person again only if they later give their consent.
Double opt-in: good practice, expected in some countries
With double opt-in, a person signs up, gets an email asking them to confirm, and only that click subscribes them. Neither the GDPR nor the ePrivacy Directive mentions it, so in most EU countries it isn't written into law. Two exceptions:
- Germany. The sender has to prove consent, and the Federal Court of Justice has held that a sign-up confirmed this way, with the consent box ticked, generally documents consent to email advertising at that address (BGH, I ZR 164/09, 10 February 2011).
- Greece. The data protection authority's Directive 2/2011 says the sender must first confirm the person has access to the address they gave. At a minimum it expects an email to that address right after sign-up, saying what they agreed to and how to withdraw; full double opt-in is the accepted alternative. The authority still cited it in its 2023 guidelines on political communication.
Even where nobody requires it, a confirmation step keeps typos, fake sign-ups and spam traps off your list, which protects your email deliverability.
Records to keep
The EDPB suggests keeping a record of each consent statement: how and when it was given, and what the person was shown. In practice, one row per change:
| Record | Example |
|---|---|
| Who | anna@example.com, customer 1042 |
| When | 2026-10-28, 14:32 |
| How and where | Newsletter box at checkout, order 18311 |
| Wording shown | "Email me offers and new products from Example Shop. Unsubscribe any time." (version 3) |
| Basis | Explicit consent, or soft opt-in |
| Later changes | Unsubscribed with the inbox's one-click button, 2026-12-02 |
Keep the history, not just a "subscribed: yes" flag: in a dispute, what counts is what was true on the day you sent.
How long can you rely on a soft opt-in?
No law sets a period. The Directive and the national laws are silent, and the ICO describes the idea as a customer who "bought something from you recently". For consent, the EDPB says the GDPR sets no time limit: it depends on the context and on what the person would expect, and it recommends refreshing consent at appropriate intervals (paragraphs 110 and 111).
A sensible rule ties the soft opt-in to activity: it lasts while the customer keeps buying or clicking in your emails, and lapses after a stretch with neither. MailPilot's default is 24 months after the customer's last purchase or last click on one of your emails, and you can change it. That is our default, not a legal limit.
Common mistakes
- Pre-ticked boxes, or consent hidden in the terms. The EDPB says pre-ticked boxes are invalid under the GDPR (paragraph 79).
- Buying or renting a list. The soft opt-in never applies, since you didn't collect the addresses, and any consent must name your shop.
- Emailing marketplace and POS buyers. A marketplace passes on details so you can deliver the order, and you never offered those buyers a way to refuse. A POS customer who gave an email for a receipt wasn't told about offers either: the ICO uses exactly that case as an example of what not to do. If your POS and online store share one system (see syncing stock with a physical store), keep those orders out of your newsletter.
- Re-subscribing someone because they bought again. An unsubscribe stands until they sign up again themselves.
- An opt-out offered too late. The chance to refuse must be there when you collect the address, not in the confirmation email.
How MailPilot handles consent
MailPilot is the email marketing module of RetailPilot, built for WooCommerce shops. It runs as a pilot, by invitation, and our team sets each shop up. On consent:
- A consent ledger per person. Every change is recorded with how, where and when, such as the newsletter box on an order or an unsubscribe, and shown on each person's page.
- Soft opt-in with an expiry. A qualifying web purchase grants it (your checkout must still offer the clear opt-out described above), it lapses 24 months after the last purchase or click (you set the period), and the check runs again right before each email leaves.
- A consent rule per automation. "Explicit consent only" is the default, meant for anything with an offer; "Customers" adds valid soft opt-ins, for offer-free emails such as a review request after delivery.
- Point-of-sale (POS), marketplace and return orders can be kept out, so they never count as web purchases or grant a soft opt-in.
- One-click unsubscribe from Gmail's or Yahoo's own button. The link in the email asks first, so link scanners can't unsubscribe anyone by accident.
- Unsubscribes stick. A later purchase never re-subscribes someone who unsubscribed.
It doesn't send sign-up confirmation emails (double opt-in), so plan that step separately where your country or your lawyer expects it. MailPilot is built to help you meet these rules; your checkout wording and your legal basis stay your decisions. RetailPilot processes your customers' data on your behalf, as our GDPR page explains.
Frequently asked questions
Can I email customers who didn't tick the newsletter box?
Yes, on a soft opt-in, if your checkout offered them a clear way to refuse, you email only about your own similar products, and every email lets them unsubscribe. Without that refusal option at checkout, the soft opt-in doesn't apply.
Is double opt-in required under the GDPR?
No, the GDPR doesn't mention it. German courts generally accept a confirmed double opt-in as proof of consent, and in Greece the data protection authority expects at least an email to the new address right after sign-up. Everywhere, it keeps bad addresses off your list.
How long can I email past customers on a soft opt-in?
No law sets a number; it depends on what customers would reasonably expect. Tie it to their last purchase or click, and stop when it lapses.
What should my newsletter checkbox say?
Plain words naming your shop, the channel and the content, with the box unticked and apart from the terms: "Email me offers and new products from Example Shop. I can unsubscribe at any time."
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules on marketing email are set nationally and change; for your own shop, ask a lawyer. The sources linked above were checked on 2 November 2026.